Cleveland Guardians (2022-present)

Cleveland Indians (1915-2021)

Cleveland Naps (1906-1914)

Cleveland Napoleons (1903-1905)

Cleveland Blues (1902)

Cleveland (1901)

New York Mets (1962-present)

Since 1933 (includes Negro League East-West Games where applicable). When paired with a team, the player must have represented that team in the All-Star Game. When paired with a non-team category, does not need to be in the same season.